On September 8, 2026, the owners of a house on Edgewood Boulevard asked Homewood's Board of Zoning Adjustments for permission to replace and screen a covered deck that was already there. They planned to keep roughly the same footprint. The board said no.
The property already exceeded the city's allowed lot coverage, and the request would have left impervious coverage at 57.92 percent. According to the city's meeting summary, the board found that not knowing about the problem when the home was purchased did not meet the required hardship standard. City staff offered to help the owners find repairs and screening work the code would allow.
Since January 2025, the board has approved second stories on College Avenue, Forest Drive South, Woodland Drive, Ardsley Place and Peerless Avenue, and it has denied requests to push coverage to 48 percent on Acton Avenue and 53 percent on La Prado Circle.
Two Percentages You Won't See on a Listing
Most of Homewood's older residential streets fall in the Neighborhood Preservation District, or NPD. The Homewood zoning ordinance, most recently revised June 10, 2025, sets two caps for that district. The primary structure can cover no more than 37 percent of the lot, and all impervious surface combined can cover no more than 45 percent.
The second cap covers more than most buyers expect. Driveways, patios, walkways and pool decks all count toward it, and the ordinance is specific about materials. Dense graded aggregate and #57 stone are treated as impervious and can't be used for driveways. A pervious driveway of permeable pavement or pea gravel can count as 50 percent pervious, but only if a registered engineer or landscape architect designs it and the City Engineer approves it. Artificial turf follows the same 50 percent rule with the same professional sign-off. In detached residential districts, turf is allowed in rear yards only.
The city checks these numbers with a survey. Before it approves any permit that adds to or changes a lot, it requires a boundary survey from a professional land surveyor. The ordinance's list includes new homes and additions, plus garages, pools, decks, fences, driveways, hardscape and artificial turf.
Twenty-One Months of Votes, Side by Side
The city posts a summary after every Board of Zoning Adjustments meeting. Read in sequence, the residential cases show a consistent pattern.
| Address | Meeting | Request | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 208 Raleigh Avenue | Jan. 9, 2025 | Side setback cut from 10 ft to 8.8 ft for an addition | Denied |
| 13 Oak Moor Drive | Nov. 6, 2025 | Enclose a nonconforming carport as a bedroom | Denied |
| 800 College Avenue | Dec. 4, 2025 | Rebuild on the existing footprint, building upward | Approved |
| 564 Forest Drive South | Dec. 4, 2025 | Second story over an existing wall | Approved |
| 216 Acton Avenue | Feb. 5, 2026 | 40.8% structure coverage, 48% impervious, 13.5 ft rear setback | Denied |
| 320 La Prado Circle | Mar. 5, 2026 | 53% impervious, 6 ft 7 in side setback | Denied |
| 422 Woodland Drive | Mar. 5, 2026 | Second-story setback | Approved |
| Ardsley Place and Peerless Avenue | Jul. 9, 2026 | Second-story additions | Approved |
| Edgewood Boulevard | Sept. 8, 2026 | Replace deck on a lot at 57.92% impervious | Denied |
| 906 Salter Road | Oct. 1, 2026 | Screened porch into rear setback, with a smaller driveway | Approved |
| 3105 Overton Drive | Oct. 1, 2026 | Side setbacks of 8.4 and 8.3 ft for renovations | Approved |
The same March 5 meeting also turned down requests at 504 Hampton Drive, 301 Ascot Road and 837 Forest Drive. After the Acton Avenue denial, the city titled its own summary of that meeting "BZA Remains Consistent On Setback Relief" and said the decision mattered because it showed the board staying consistent on lot coverage and setback relief.
The Variance Standard and Recent Decisions
Before granting any variance, the board must find that all of a list of conditions exist. The first is "extraordinary and exceptional conditions" peculiar to the property "because of its size, shape or topography." The ordinance then lists what can't count as an unnecessary hardship: proof that a variance would increase financial return, personal or economic hardship, and self-imposed hardship. Any variance granted must be "the minimum adjustment necessary." Under the board's rules, printed in its February 2026 agenda packet, approval also takes four concurring votes. At Oak Moor Drive, the motion to approve fell short of the four required.
The College Avenue owners proposed keeping their foundation and building up. The Forest Drive South addition went over an existing wall 7.7 feet from the side line, with no change to the first-floor footprint. Both were approved in December 2025.
The October 2026 approvals rested on the land itself. At 906 Salter Road, a steep, narrow lot limited where an addition could go, and the approval came with a smaller driveway that brings the property within the paved-surface limits. At 3105 Overton Drive, the city's summary cites an unusual lot shape, steep terrain, a house already inside the required setbacks, and plans that would also fix drainage problems and failing retaining walls. In July, a pool on Gran Avenue was approved with what the city described as a 105-square-foot increase in impervious surfacing. Its summary says the project would still stay within the maximum, at about 44.6 percent.
The Oak Moor Drive denial shows the other side. The applicant said building elsewhere on the lot would cost far more, and the board responded that personal and financial hardship can't be the legal basis for a variance.
The Edgewood Boulevard and La Prado Circle Cases
Many older Homewood homes were built, paved and added onto over decades. In the September case, the board found that being unaware of the overage at purchase did not meet the hardship standard.
The 320 La Prado Circle case adds another lesson. Its February hearing was continued because the impervious calculations might not reflect recent changes to the property, including a deck that had been removed and rebuilt. When the case returned in March, it was denied. A rebuilt deck was enough to put the lot's impervious figure in question at the hearing.
Greater Alabama MLS figures for September 1, 2025 through August 31, 2026 show 341 residential closings citywide at a $565,000 median price, with a median of four days on market.
If you're weighing an older Homewood house or getting ready to list one, Jake Callahan can help. Request a free home valuation and consultation.